signs of hope

Feb 21, 2021

Each August in Italy since 1980 tens of thousands of people attend a week-long gathering that is so well-known it is simply referred to as The Meeting.

The days are rich with seminars, lectures, exhibitions and entertainment around a focus involving the life of the heart, relationships and hope for the future lived in the present. The theme of the 2020 meeting gives an indication of the depth and breadth of the content: Devoid of Wonder, we remain Deaf to the Sublime.

In recent years other countries have developed their own form of this meeting and for the past ten years the New York Encounter has been a calendar highlight for many.

Last weekend the NY gathering took place as a virtual event online giving many others an opportunity to participate. The opening speaker was Archbishop Pierbattista Pizzaballa, the Latin patriarch of Jerusalem. In his reflection he suggests that we often confuse optimism and hope. He goes on to explain how optimism and hope are not the same thing.

An optimist is one who thinks that everything will be OK. The hopeful person finds meaning in every circumstance.

An optimist survives knowing that present struggles will not last forever. Optimism is not a bad thing. We are optimistic that a vaccine will put an end to the current pandemic,

However hope is a much deeper quality. Hope gives meaning, a purpose to whatever we are living, even when our present is heavy with unwanted and unwarranted suffering. A person of hope will naturally have optimism that a Covid cure will be found. But the hopeful person also knows that optimism is not enough and that life is to be lived in every moment, even and especially in difficult situations.

The optimist can survive. The hopeful person can live.

In these first days of Lent I have been thinking a lot about the Archbishop’s comment and today the thought is renewed in me in the liturgy as God presents the rainbow to Noah, the sign of the Covenant relationship God is establishing with every living creature.

God offers relationship and leaves us free to respond or not. The inclusivity of God’s covenant does not mean that everyone is automatically included whether they choose this or not. Instead God’s inclusive covenant offers relationship to everyone who accepts this gift.

Because God has entered relationship with us, this does not mean we are magically freed from suffering.Hope is grounded in the fact that something better than positive thinking is offered to us.

There is meaning in every suffering, and once we accept this we find we have the awareness to seek and find this meaning and so find ourselves living in hope.

An Invitation:

  • Take a moment to ponder the difference between optimism and hope. Think of a suffering or anxiety that you carry today. Invite Jesus to reveal to you some meaning in this and so to give you hope.
  • The reflection above is based on the first reading from today‘s liturgy. There is a FFF video reflection (from a few years ago) on today’s gospel (temptation of Jesus) at this link.
  • A number of people have requested the FFF prayer list be started again. So send initials of those you wish me to add. You might like to add a word or two about the intention. Send requests to and know that the FFF team are praying with you.
  • Today’s Lectio (below) uses both the first reading and gospel from today’s liturgy.
  • I thought you might appreciate the picture above, snapped on the North Shore in Auckland a couple of months ago.

Lectio Divina 15 minutes

Lectio Divina 25 minutes


  1. Yes the wonder of the rainbow
    Not for a ‘pot of gold’
    But a realisation (hope) there is a bigger plan ..

  2. Thank you Father John for the beautiful differentiation of Optimism and Hope. Both are good but Hope is better! God bless 🙂

    • Amen thank you Father John for beautiful Rainbow photo Amen

  3. I was reflecting on the Hope and in my mind I saw an image, as if I was looking down on the cross. from above ,and behind Jesus. The glimpse was between Jesus and the cross. Deathly pale arms outstretched and and dark head slumped forward and down.
    I thought ‘Where is the Hope in that?’

    I have a sore painful neck and arms and am find the metastasized cancer in my arms and neck, combined with arthritis makes life a challenge .So I said ‘ok here goes, I unite my suffering to Yours.’
    Then the resurrection came to mind. My Hope! …I hope.

    • Clever photo The distinction between hope and optimism is something I’ve never considered before. Food for thought…thank you.

  4. “Optimism-hope,”
    Fr John for opening my mind
    With those Two Words, and the different take on them,I will share at the
    In conversation,with others.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Posts

growing young

growing young

A simple experiment will give a more personal experience of the life that is on offer.

sky gazing

sky gazing

The disciples were full of joy at the Lord’s definitive departure. We would have expected the opposite.

farm time

farm time

Now there’s a sabbatical inspiration: learning to wait. Yes I might plant seeds, but God brings the harvest.



There people gather on their own turangawaewae, the place where they stand, lead and are most at home